Friday, April 27, 2018

Navigating the Problematic Realities of Private vs. Public Prisons




Walnut Grove is a small town in Mississippi, just about three hours from Memphis, and it was the site of Walnut Grove Youth Correctional Facility. The facility was a private youth prison that faced multiple complaint reports of organized fights, violent brawls that were not stopped by guards and guards forcing inmates to perform sexual acts in exchange for food. According to reporting by the research team for the podcast Criminal the inmates of Walnut Grove were about 80% African American, although Mississippi as a whole was only about 35%.[1] There is no separating race and pervasive corruption in the prison system. The demographics alone are representative of the school-to-prison pipeline, but the prejudiced perspectives of the prison staff and town further enhance the despicable reality of the system. A former guard described the inmates as “not children who disobeyed their parents [but] hardened criminals … [who] had a problem with society,” other town members responded to the reports of misconduct and brutality in the facility with dismissive statements like: “Well it is a prison, and you’re gonna have problems in a prison.”[2] The Department of Justice concluded in their investigation that the prison was “not adequately protecting” the inmates. Walnut Grove was converted to an adult facility and later shut down. Many people living in Walnut Grove are unhappy with the decision though, as the prison was the main employer for the area and the town has been nearly bankrupted by the loss of revenue.

Public prisons are often no better than private prisons. Prisons in Arizona are facing federal sanctions in response to mistreatment of inmates. The healthcare provider Corizon, which employs specialists for jails and provides healthcare resources to many public prisons, is being sued by thousands of inmates for withholding medications and treatments. The complaints include withholding access to  medication from inmates suffering from AIDS, seizure disorders, and even those presenting with heart attack symptoms.[3] There was already a settlement in 2012 that was supposed to improve the quality of care provided by Corizon, but a new investigation reveals little has changed; testimony in the case was recently heard by a federal judge.

Prison conditions across the country are abusive and inhumane, and when the system intentionally targets black men more than any other group, it’s not just a human rights violation, it is a hate crime.



[1] Pheobe Judge, Walnut Grove, Criminal, n.d., http://www.thisiscriminal.com/episode-58-walnut-grove-1-6-2017.
[2] Judge.
[3] Jimmy Jenkins, “Arizona Prisons Face Federal Sanctions Over Prisoners’ Health Care : NPR,” March 2, 2018, https://www.npr.org/2018/03/02/590121817/arizona-prisons-face-federal-sanctions-over-prisoners-health-care.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Busing

Education is a key policy to any functioning community.  It provides the tools necessary fro achievement and success.  It also divides us an...